Thought dump

Presenting my thoughts, stories and ideas to the world

10th November 2026

Selling Pokémon cards on Whatnot: the numbers to check before you go live

Whatnot is a live video marketplace: card sellers run scheduled shows and sell singles, graded slabs and bulk lots in timed auctions that often end in sudden death. The format decides what a card is worth on your show. Buyers see each lot on camera for a few seconds, bid in the moment, and compare your price to completed sales they remember, not to a price guide. That makes your preparation, not your presentation, the part that moves the needle.

Price the singles before you build the lot

Work out a price for each raw and graded card first, using recent sold results and the PSA 9 and PSA 10 values for the card, then group the leftovers into bulk or mystery lots. Keep lot titles boring and searchable: set, year, card number, grade and language. A buyer who can find the lot again in a recording is a buyer who comes back to the next show.

Do the grading maths before the show, not after

Grading is a cost you pay up front: a flat per-card fee, shipping both ways, insurance and weeks of turnaround. The card only pays you back if it comes back at the grade that changes the value. For each slab candidate, compare the raw price you could sell for today with the graded value at the grade you expect, after grading fees, shipping and the marketplace fee on the sale. Cards that are close call raw are usually worth sending; cards that need an exact gem grade to pay are a gamble with your own cash flow.

Know the fee shape, not just the fee

Whatnot takes a selling fee on each order, a percentage of the sale plus a fixed amount, and payment processing sits on top. The published rates move, so read the current seller help pages before you price, then work the fee into your minimum lot price. A fixed per order fee is small on a $200 slab and heavy on a $6 lot, which is why thin bulk lots and free shipping rarely work on live shows.

Time the show to the hobby calendar

Demand for specific cards jumps around set releases, restock news and tournament seasons. Schedule the same night each week so regulars know when to show up, and plan your strongest lots for the first hour, when the room is fullest. Have a stated shipping price and a dispatch day on screen: returns and complaints, not the auction, are what quietly kill a card shop margin.

We keep a longer, plain walkthrough of how to sell on Whatnot, covering show setup, fees, shipping and lot design, and more card seller guides at Greedy TCG.